Snape, **SPOILERS??** Options

[moose]

After re-reading the GoF I have found some very interesting hints as to why Snape is acting with the Order, not the Death-Eaters.


If you look @ pg 651 in GoF it is the scene where Voldemort is talking to the DE's in the graveyard he says 6 are missing. 3 dead, one too cowardly to return (Karkaroff), ONE WHO HE BELIEVES HAS LEFT HIM FOREVER (SNAPE??) that will be killed, and his most faithful servant who is @ Hogwarts and is responsible for Harry being there(crouch).

Then near the end of the book in the hospital wing Dumbledore says this to Snape: "Severus, you know what I must ask you to do. If you are ready....If you are prepared..." Snape says "I am" While looking paler than usual and his cold, black eyes glittering strangely.


It is obvious that Dumbledore wants him to go and act as a double again. In the beggining of HBP Snape tells Lestrange that Voldemort trusts him. Since Snape is so good @ occlumency he might have been able to hide the fact that is really with the Order from him and said that he had been waiting for his return while staying at Hogwarts.



That's why I think Snape is still good.

[hpfan69]

so baty you think that dd is not dead?

i do beleive some of what wizard of aus has said. but i do think that dd is dead. i don't think that his picture would have appeared in his office and on the wall by coincedence. (i think i spelled that right 06<_< ) unless there was a spell to make it appear even though he is not dead. that is "if" he is not dead. i am very weary of this theory.

[baty4potter]

so baty you think that dd is not dead?

i do beleive some of what wizard of aus has said. but i do think that dd is dead. i don't think that his picture would have appeared in his office and on the wall by coincedence. (i think i spelled that right  06<_< ) unless there was a spell to make it appear even though he is not dead. that is "if" he is not dead. i am very weary of this theory.
[right][snapback]84835[/snapback][/right]

Think about it this way.... If you were going to fake your death, and you wanted it to look real, you'd *have* to put a portrait there otherwise *everyone* would wonder what was going on. So the portrait means nothing. Well to me it doesn't. lol